I give yahoo a better rating than match for one simple reason,
they don't make any promises.
it is what it is!,a tool to help busy people meet.
or for shy people to make contact in a safer way that random chance in a bar or club.
I have had fewer dates from yahoo ,mostly due to lack of interest on my part,for a change I was the one being picky..
not that this was a good thing.match has done some damage to my confidence in on line dating,sadly yahoo hasn't been able to restore any of it.
other than my personal hangups
its not a bad site
And I haven't had one fake profile yet!
even the Russian chicks were almost honest about where they were from the very start of communications.
good luck and good hunting.